Overhaul of surrogacy and reproductive laws โ€˜a long time in the incubatorโ€™

The WA government this week introduced landmark legislation to increase access to assisted reproductive technology (ART) and surrogacy in the state.โ€ฏย 


The Assisted Reproductive Technology and Surrogacy Bill 2025 introduced to Parliament this week will remove long-standing barriers to access, enabling same-sex couples, single people, transgender and intersex West Australians to access ART and surrogacy.โ€ฏโ€ฏย 

The changes will bring WA in line with much of the rest of the country.โ€ฏย 

The Bill aims to ensure the best interests of children born through ART and surrogacy are paramount and maintains safety and quality assurances through the licensing of fertility clinics by the Department of Health, the State Government said in a statement.โ€ฏโ€ฏย 

It will also extend the rights of donor-conceived people, where records are available, to access important information about their genetic heritage, regardless of when they were conceived, to help them make better informed decisions about family planning and healthcare decisions.ย 

Health Minister Meredith Hammat said the reforms were about helping more people realise their dreams of starting a family.ย 

RELATED: Left holding the baby โ€“ WAโ€™s surrogacy and ART lawsย 

Concept Fertility Centre General Manager Jen Chambers welcomed the reform as long overdue, adding that the legislation had been โ€œa long time in the incubator so to speakโ€.โ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏย 

โ€œFirst and foremost, this news is about equality,โ€ she said.ย 

โ€œFor too long now our ART and surrogacy legislation has not served West Australians equally.โ€โ€ฏโ€ฏย 

WAโ€™s Surrogacy Act came into place in 2008, legalising surrogacy for heterosexual couples. Surrogacy for sex couples, single people, transgender and intersex people has lagged behind.ย 

In 2019 Associate Professor Sonia Allan completed an independent review (the Allan Review) into the existing state laws. A two-part report was published as part of this review and as a result a Ministerial Expert Panel was convened in May 2022 to ensure new legislation reflected social trends alongside medical and scientific advances for the accessible and safe use of ART and surrogacy.โ€ฏย 

The expert panelโ€™s review the stateโ€™s surrogacy and ART laws was completed by 2022 and found them to be outdated and discriminatory.ย 

Ms Chambers has coordinated Concept Fertilityโ€™s surrogacy program for the past five years and said the Subiaco-based clinic had been involved in the process of seeing four babies born to surrogacy in the past two years.โ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏย 

โ€œOver this time, I have had many conversations with same sex couples wanting to pursue same sex surrogacy and each conversation ended the same โ€“ โ€˜Itโ€™s not legal in WA but please don’t lose hope, change will come, so letโ€™s keep in touchโ€™,โ€ she said.โ€ฏย 

Ms Chambers said if the legislation goes through, she will welcome not having to have that conversation.ย 

Concept Fertility Centreโ€™s Medical Director Dr Sebastian Leathersich added that while WA was one of the first jurisdictions in the world to regulate ART and IVF in 1991, now that those laws were more 30 years old, they were outdated and no longer fit for purpose.โ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏย 

RELATED: Male infertility: why sperm counts are fallingโ€ฏย 

โ€œThese long overdue reforms reflect contemporary societal values and, if passed, will make it easier for West Australians to access ART without needing to travel interstate or overseas,โ€ he said.โ€ฏย 

โ€œIn particular, same-sex couples, single people and gender-diverse West Australians will be able to access IVF and surrogacy, helping them to start and build their families.โ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏย 

โ€œThe proposed legislation will also remove other barriers to fertility treatment such as the need to โ€˜proveโ€™ infertility before offering IVF, as well as some of the restrictions on pre-implantation genetic testing, giving patients and clinicians the autonomy to choose the best path to parenthood for their specific situation.โ€โ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏย 

A review in 2022 found WAโ€™s surrogacy and ART laws to be outdated and discriminatory.

Monash IVF West Medical Director Dr Tamara Hunter also welcomed the legislation.ย 

โ€œWe must do more to support those who require fertility treatment to start their families, regardless of their circumstances,โ€ she said.ย 

โ€œThis legislation is a step in the right direction and we look forward to seeing meaningful change in the near future.โ€ย 

RELATED: Closing fertility knowledge gaps โ€“ new insights for GPsย 

Dr Leathersich described the more than 40 individual pieces of legislation governing ART and IVF across Australia as a patchwork of laws.โ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏย 

โ€œWith increasing demand for ART anticipated over coming years, national harmonisation of the legislative and regulatory environment should be prioritised so that all Australians can access the same care regardless of where they live.โ€โ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏย 

Dr Leathersich said it was vital for clinics and clinicians to ensure they are compliant within this tightly regulated area of medical practice.โ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏย 

โ€œThe Ministerial Expert Panel recommended that the expansion of eligibility criteria for ART be implemented as soon as possible, so clinics will need to be prepared for these changes,โ€ he said.โ€ฏโ€ฏโ€ฏย 

โ€œThis includes educating staff and updating systems, protocols, and processes to support implementation of the improved access to reproductive care, whilst keeping the wellbeing of any child that might be born from ART at the centre of any clinical decisions made.โ€โ€ฏย 


Want more news, clinicals, features and guest columns delivered straight to you?ย Subscribe for freeย to WAโ€™s only independent magazine for medical practitioners.

Want to submit an article? Emailย editor@mforum.com.au